Incentivizing Early Morning and Late Evening Shifts?

  • Incentivizing Early Morning and Late Evening Shifts?

    Posted by jessekoch on March 30, 2023 at 9:54 am

    Hi Everyone!

    In recent years, we’ve struggled to get student staff to fill our less desirable shifts. The main shifts in question are our Friday/Saturday late night shifts and our Saturday/Sunday early morning shifts.?

    Currently, we offer a $1/hr bonus for any shift that starts prior to 9am on weekends, and all shifts that end at midnight or later regardless of day of the week.?

    We have a few ideas on how we can address the issue, but I’m hoping to get some wisdom from this community! What you all do to get those difficult shifts filled? Do you offer a financial incentive (if so, how much)? Do you assign by seniority? I’m open to any suggestions and best practices!

    ——————————
    Jesse Koch
    Associate Director
    Carnegie Mellon University
    Pittsburgh PA
    ——————————

    kdyleski replied 3 years, 1 month ago 7 Members · 6 Replies
  • 6 Replies
  • lchase

    Member
    March 30, 2023 at 2:23 pm

    Hi Jesse,?

    We did the following for our building managers in my previous position but we were closed on weekends so events were only scheduled sporadically on the weekend not every weekend:?

    1. All weekend shifts and late-night shifts were paid at time and a half?
    2. At the beginning of every semester, students signed up for weekends, if an event was scheduled on their weekend they would have to come in and work it or get it covered. If there wasn’t an event scheduled they were free that weekend.?

    I think the combination of these two things helped me ensure all our late-night or weekend shifts were covered while still allowing everyone to feel like they had plenty of notice to plan their life accordingly. Hope this helps!?

    ——————————
    Laurel Chase
    Operations Manager – Temple University – Howard Gittis Student Center
    Temple University
    Philadelphia PA
    ——————————
    ——————————————-
    Original Message:
    Sent: 03-30-2023 09:53
    From: Jesse Koch
    Subject: Incentivizing Early Morning and Late Evening Shifts?

    Hi Everyone!

    In recent years, we’ve struggled to get student staff to fill our less desirable shifts. The main shifts in question are our Friday/Saturday late night shifts and our Saturday/Sunday early morning shifts. 

    Currently, we offer a $1/hr bonus for any shift that starts prior to 9am on weekends, and all shifts that end at midnight or later regardless of day of the week. 

    We have a few ideas on how we can address the issue, but I’m hoping to get some wisdom from this community! What you all do to get those difficult shifts filled? Do you offer a financial incentive (if so, how much)? Do you assign by seniority? I’m open to any suggestions and best practices!

    ——————————
    Jesse Koch
    Associate Director
    Carnegie Mellon University
    Pittsburgh PA
    ——————————

    • Kathy Hewlett

      Member
      March 30, 2023 at 2:43 pm

      At SUNY Oneonta we have HUb Associates and Building Managers who work during our hours of operation – Monday – Saturday. We are closed on Sunday’s.

      We close at 11pm – some times events run later on Friday and Saturday, late closes could be 12-12:30 am. We provide them with these dates ahead of time.

      Students are provided with this information when the apply for positions.

      Building managers are paid a higher wage than our HUb Associates. 

      Student employee work hours are done by seniority. We have rotating shifts on Friday and Saturday evenings until close so no one is working every weekend.

      If there is a conflict, they work together to make changes.  Shift trades are recommended for their normal shifts (usually 7-8 hours per week), but must trade rotating shifts so no one person is working many rotating shifts.

      Typically each student works 2 Friday  and 2 Saturday rotating shifts per semester.

       

      Kathy L Hewlett

      Agency Services Representative

      HUb Supervisor/Box Office Manager

      Office of Student Life and Leadership

      SUNY Oneonta

      124 Hunt Union

      607-436-3722

       

      Strengths – Consistency, Communication, Empathy, Individualization, Discipline

       

      “I’m not what I think I am, I’m not what you think I am, I’m what I think you think I am”  Cooley

       

      “Be who you are and say what you feel, because those who mind don’t matter and those who matter don’t mind.” Dr. Seuss

       

       

      ——————————————-
      Original Message:
      Sent: 3/30/2023 2:23:00 PM
      From: Laurel Chase
      Subject: RE: Incentivizing Early Morning and Late Evening Shifts?

      Hi Jesse, 

      We did the following for our building managers in my previous position but we were closed on weekends so events were only scheduled sporadically on the weekend not every weekend: 

      1. All weekend shifts and late-night shifts were paid at time and a half 
      2. At the beginning of every semester, students signed up for weekends, if an event was scheduled on their weekend they would have to come in and work it or get it covered. If there wasn’t an event scheduled they were free that weekend. 

      I think the combination of these two things helped me ensure all our late-night or weekend shifts were covered while still allowing everyone to feel like they had plenty of notice to plan their life accordingly. Hope this helps! 

      ——————————
      Laurel Chase
      Operations Manager – Temple University – Howard Gittis Student Center
      Temple University
      Philadelphia PA
      ——————————
      ——————————————-
      Original Message:
      Sent: 03-30-2023 09:53
      From: Jesse Koch
      Subject: Incentivizing Early Morning and Late Evening Shifts?

      Hi Everyone!

      In recent years, we’ve struggled to get student staff to fill our less desirable shifts. The main shifts in question are our Friday/Saturday late night shifts and our Saturday/Sunday early morning shifts. 

      Currently, we offer a $1/hr bonus for any shift that starts prior to 9am on weekends, and all shifts that end at midnight or later regardless of day of the week. 

      We have a few ideas on how we can address the issue, but I’m hoping to get some wisdom from this community! What you all do to get those difficult shifts filled? Do you offer a financial incentive (if so, how much)? Do you assign by seniority? I’m open to any suggestions and best practices!

      ——————————
      Jesse Koch
      Associate Director
      Carnegie Mellon University
      Pittsburgh PA
      ——————————

  • Chrissie Taylor

    Member
    March 30, 2023 at 2:58 pm

    Hi Jesse,?

    Here at Rutgers-Camden, we use WhentoWork for scheduling.? I have our students paint their availability in the summer and then again in late fall.? I create the schedule based on number of hours per week they are looking for and then that schedule is the same schedule for the entire semester.? We open at 7am, so staff come in at 6:50am and we close at 11pm, so staff stay until 11:30pm.? If there are events or flips for events in the morning, I extend their hours and they stay to get it done.? Most times, this is not later than 12:30am.? I will also add on an extra shift for staff to pick up to help get the work done quicker, so they do not have to be here later.? We do not pay any more $$ for any shifts and for the most part, we typically do not have any issue getting all shifts covered.? If we do, we do the same that others have mentioned where we do a rotation; this would happen usually for a Friday or Saturday night shift.? I also make sure that when people come to information sessions, the required hours are mentioned and also include it in their contract.? Hope this helps!

    ——————————
    Chrissie King
    Assistant Director
    Rutgers University Camden
    Camden NJ
    chrissie.king@rutgers.edu
    ——————————
    ——————————————-
    Original Message:
    Sent: 03-30-2023 09:53
    From: Jesse Koch
    Subject: Incentivizing Early Morning and Late Evening Shifts?

    Hi Everyone!

    In recent years, we’ve struggled to get student staff to fill our less desirable shifts. The main shifts in question are our Friday/Saturday late night shifts and our Saturday/Sunday early morning shifts. 

    Currently, we offer a $1/hr bonus for any shift that starts prior to 9am on weekends, and all shifts that end at midnight or later regardless of day of the week. 

    We have a few ideas on how we can address the issue, but I’m hoping to get some wisdom from this community! What you all do to get those difficult shifts filled? Do you offer a financial incentive (if so, how much)? Do you assign by seniority? I’m open to any suggestions and best practices!

    ——————————
    Jesse Koch
    Associate Director
    Carnegie Mellon University
    Pittsburgh PA
    ——————————

  • suenagaj

    Member
    March 31, 2023 at 3:15 am

    Hello!?
    We pay our students $0.60 extra per hour starting at 6 pm until 6 am, every day.? Our students are informed of early, late and weekend shifts when they are hired and we make sure they all understand this.? We are open M-F 8 am-9 pm, Saturday 8 am-5 pm, and closed Sundays. Each week we make the schedule according to the events and try to make sure that no student is closing late or opening early more than 2 times per week.? We usually get some students that like morning shifts and ones that like evening shifts, so it usually works out.? Weekends are rotated so staff are not working 2 weekends in a row, but if they do, we give them 2 weekends off. We also have 3 student managers who cover shifts when the full time staff are not present. They get paid more so they usually don?t mind working more.??

    ——————————
    Jacy Cutitta
    Operations Coordinator
    University of Hawaii?Manoa
    Kaneohe HI
    ——————————
    ——————————————-
    Original Message:
    Sent: 03-30-2023 09:53
    From: Jesse Koch
    Subject: Incentivizing Early Morning and Late Evening Shifts?

    Hi Everyone!

    In recent years, we’ve struggled to get student staff to fill our less desirable shifts. The main shifts in question are our Friday/Saturday late night shifts and our Saturday/Sunday early morning shifts. 

    Currently, we offer a $1/hr bonus for any shift that starts prior to 9am on weekends, and all shifts that end at midnight or later regardless of day of the week. 

    We have a few ideas on how we can address the issue, but I’m hoping to get some wisdom from this community! What you all do to get those difficult shifts filled? Do you offer a financial incentive (if so, how much)? Do you assign by seniority? I’m open to any suggestions and best practices!

    ——————————
    Jesse Koch
    Associate Director
    Carnegie Mellon University
    Pittsburgh PA
    ——————————

    • tcol0630

      Member
      April 3, 2023 at 10:41 am

      Hi there,

       

      This was a concern for us a few years ago but have since established a weekend late night rotating model. We rotate the full team so that no one is getting a standard late shift. At the start of the semester, we establish who is scheduled for each weekend shift. The students work amongst themselves to trade if necessary but the expectation is they are doing at least 1-2 closings per shift. Toward the end of the spring we bring on our new team and they use the closings on the weekends as a training opportunity so they do it in teams which frees up some dates.

       

      Hope this is helpful.

      Best,
      Tiff

       

       

      Tiffany Brodner She/Hers/Her
      Associate Director for Building Operations
      Center for Campus Life
      Student Affairs
      Rochester Institute of Technology
      Campus Center 1040
      34 Lomb Memorial Drive
      Rochester NY 14623

      W: 585-475-6931
      tbccl@rit.edu

      RIT | Rochester Institute of Technology


      CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: The contents of this email message and any attachments are intended solely for the addressee(s) and may contain confidential and/or privileged information and may be legally protected from disclosure. If you are not the intended recipient of this message or their agent, or if this message has been addressed to you in error, please immediately alert the sender by reply email and then delete this message and any attachments. If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any use, dissemination, copying, or storage of this message or its attachments is strictly prohibited.

       

      ——————————————-
      Original Message:
      Sent: 3/31/2023 3:15:00 AM
      From: Jacy Cutitta
      Subject: RE: Incentivizing Early Morning and Late Evening Shifts?

      Hello! 
      We pay our students $0.60 extra per hour starting at 6 pm until 6 am, every day.  Our students are informed of early, late and weekend shifts when they are hired and we make sure they all understand this.  We are open M-F 8 am-9 pm, Saturday 8 am-5 pm, and closed Sundays. Each week we make the schedule according to the events and try to make sure that no student is closing late or opening early more than 2 times per week.  We usually get some students that like morning shifts and ones that like evening shifts, so it usually works out.  Weekends are rotated so staff are not working 2 weekends in a row, but if they do, we give them 2 weekends off. We also have 3 student managers who cover shifts when the full time staff are not present. They get paid more so they usually don?t mind working more.  

      ——————————
      Jacy Cutitta
      Operations Coordinator
      University of Hawaii?Manoa
      Kaneohe HI
      ——————————
      ——————————————-
      Original Message:
      Sent: 03-30-2023 09:53
      From: Jesse Koch
      Subject: Incentivizing Early Morning and Late Evening Shifts?

      Hi Everyone!

      In recent years, we’ve struggled to get student staff to fill our less desirable shifts. The main shifts in question are our Friday/Saturday late night shifts and our Saturday/Sunday early morning shifts. 

      Currently, we offer a $1/hr bonus for any shift that starts prior to 9am on weekends, and all shifts that end at midnight or later regardless of day of the week. 

      We have a few ideas on how we can address the issue, but I’m hoping to get some wisdom from this community! What you all do to get those difficult shifts filled? Do you offer a financial incentive (if so, how much)? Do you assign by seniority? I’m open to any suggestions and best practices!

      ——————————
      Jesse Koch
      Associate Director
      Carnegie Mellon University
      Pittsburgh PA
      ——————————

  • kdyleski

    Member
    April 7, 2023 at 8:20 pm

    Hi Jesse,?

    I have a weekend rotation model that students are made aware of during the interview process.? Friday close (7pm-11pm), Saturday (7:30am-1pm, 1pm-6pm, 6pm-11pm) and Sunday (1pm-6pm, and 6pm-11pm) all rotate through the entire staff for the entire semester.? They are allowed to switch or find coverage as needed, and for the most part this works well for both Building Managers and Info Desk Attendants. There are no additional funds to offer, so we do our best to assign the less desirable shifts as fairly as possible across the team.?

    ——————————
    Kaitlyn Dyleski
    Associate Director, Student Development & RSU Operations
    Bridgewater State University
    Bridgewater MA
    ——————————
    ——————————————-
    Original Message:
    Sent: 03-30-2023 09:53
    From: Jesse Koch
    Subject: Incentivizing Early Morning and Late Evening Shifts?

    Hi Everyone!

    In recent years, we’ve struggled to get student staff to fill our less desirable shifts. The main shifts in question are our Friday/Saturday late night shifts and our Saturday/Sunday early morning shifts. 

    Currently, we offer a $1/hr bonus for any shift that starts prior to 9am on weekends, and all shifts that end at midnight or later regardless of day of the week. 

    We have a few ideas on how we can address the issue, but I’m hoping to get some wisdom from this community! What you all do to get those difficult shifts filled? Do you offer a financial incentive (if so, how much)? Do you assign by seniority? I’m open to any suggestions and best practices!

    ——————————
    Jesse Koch
    Associate Director
    Carnegie Mellon University
    Pittsburgh PA
    ——————————

Log in to reply.